Strotty's Blog

All your Wisconsin sports news and more!

My Take: 25 Questions on 24 vs. 23

Earlier today, I was reading an article on that paneled seven experts from the website and compared LeBron James and Kobe Bryant in 25 categories.  You can read the article and results here, but here’s my take on each of the categories. (In parentheses after the question is the result of the ESPN vote).

1. Who Has Better Nicknames? (Kobe wins 4-3)

Kobe goes by “Black Mamba” while LeBron is called “The Chosen One” and “King James”.  Personally, I can not figure out why Kobe won this one.  Most reporters and analysts refer to LeBron as “King James” while the Black Mamba is much less known to most.  My Take: LeBron

2. Who Makes Better Commercials? (LeBron wins 7-0)

I have to agree with the analysts here as LeBron has put out some very good commercials recently.  “The LeBrons” are hilarious and I can not remember the last commercial that Kobe did for Nike.  My Take: LeBron

3. Who Would Win A Spelling Bee? (Kobe wins 7-0)

Kobe seems like a smarter guy than LeBron to start with, but the fact that Kobe knows Italian gives him the easy edge here.  He definitely has his languages down pat and would take the spelling bee.  My Take: Kobe

A one-on-game between the Black Mamba and King James would be one for the ages.

A one-on-game between the Black Mamba and King James would be one for the ages.

4. Whose Tell-All Twitter Feed Would You Rather Follow? (LeBron wins 5-2)

LeBron is quite the jokester and, being younger, seems to have more fun off the court.  He is very good friends with Jay-Z and I would love to see what the two of them do on a regular basis.  LeBron is definitely a fun dude.  My Take: LeBron

5. Who Will Have The More Interesting Life After Basketball? (LeBron wins 4-3)

LeBron may gain more maturity as he goes on, but right now he is all about being in the spotlight and making as much money as he can.  While there is nothing wrong with that, I can see him being in the business world (somewhat like MJ) well after he is done on the court.  My Take: LeBron

6. Who Would Win a 100-Meter Race? (LeBron wins 6-1)

Watching LeBron on the fast break leads me to believe he would take this category.  Kobe plays outstanding defense and is very quick but James’ strides would take Kobe in this one.  My Take: LeBron

7. Who Would Win A Marathon? (Kobe wins 7-0)

I have to go ahead and agree with the analysts here that Kobe would take the cake in a marathon.  The guy seems to never get tired down the stretch, regardless of how many minutes he has played.  My Take: Kobe

8. Who Would Be The Better Football Player? (LeBron wins 6-1)

This is really interesting because I don’t know what position LeBron would play.  Wide receiver makes the most sense, but at 6’8″, is he too big?  I am going to take Kobe here because I think he would play wide receiver and dominate.  He’s the perfect size (6’5″) and at this point is probably a little more agile than LeBron.  King James is a physical freak, but Kobe is no slouch. My Take: Kobe

9. Who Would Be The Better Soccer Player? (Kobe wins 7-0)

Not too fond of this question, but the agility and endurance factor that Kobe has makes me believe he would be the better soccer player.  He can also speak Italian, so yeah. My Take: Kobe

10. Who Would Win In The Octagon? (LeBron wins 6-1)

Both of these guys have the heart of a champion but LeBron’s size advantage has to give him the nod here.  He is a physical specimen and has close to 60 pounds on Kobe.  No one can stop LeBron as he goes through the lane, so I’d hate to see someone have to stop him as he does the same thing without a basketball.  My Take: LeBron

It's hard to argue with what LeBron James did on the high school hardwood.

It's hard to argue with what LeBron James did on the high school hardwood.

11. Who Had The Better High School Years? (LeBron wins 7-0)

This is a tough one for Kobe who was absolutely dominant in high school.  Unfortunately, LeBron was just as good and had ESPN in his high school every waking moment. He went undefeated his senior year and won a state title with four of his best friends.  My Take: LeBron

12. Who Was Better At Age 24? (LeBron wins 6-1)

Kobe did have a pair of rings when he was 24 years old, but having Shaquille O’Neal on his team will always make people wonder.  LeBron has done everything on his own and is poised to make a championship run this year with absolutely no help.  Tough call here but I have to go with King James.  My Take:LeBron

13. Who Has Had The Better Career So Far? (Kobe wins 7-0)

Kind of an unfair question as there is no argument for LeBron.  Kobe has been around much longer and has the three rings that LeBron does not.  At 30 years old, Kobe is still performing at such a high rate that LeBron is not even gaining that much ground on him.  My Take: Kobe

14. Who Will Finish With The Better Career? (LeBron wins 7-0)

Just because LeBron took home all seven votes does not mean it was by that much.  Stat-wise, LeBron will surpass Kobe in just about every category but the verdict is still out on whether or not LeBron will win three (or more titles).  I’ll give it to James by a hair.  My Take: LeBron

Kobe Bryant does not get enough credit for the wisdom and coaching he gives to his teammates.

Kobe Bryant does not get enough credit for the wisdom and coaching he gives to his teammates.

15. Who Is A Better Leader? (Lebron wins 6-1)

Everyone knows about how the Cavaliers bench has more fun than any team in the NBA and how LeBron can corral a team and make them all believe.  However, I am one of the few that believes Kobe gets the short end on how good of a teammate he really is.  Ballhog or not, Kobe makes everyone around him better and is great on the bench and off the court.  Give me Kobe all day.  My Take: Kobe

16. Who Has Had Better Dunks? (LeBron wins 6-1)

This was one of the easier ones for me to pick as LeBron has some of the most amazing dunks that I have ever seen.  It’s not just on the fast break that he does it, either.  He will drive to the hoop where two defenders are waiting and still throw it down.  He elevates like no one else I have seen and can get the crowd going with a slam home.  My Take: LeBron

17. Who Will Finish With More MVP Titles? (LeBron wins 7-0)

Considering that LeBron has already tied Kobe I will have to go with him in a landslide here.  Steve Nash has more MVP awards than Kobe and he has gotten hosed on a few trophies, but that is neither here nor there.  I will go out on a limb and say that LeBron will have at least five MVP’s when it is all said and done (same as MJ).  My Take: LeBron

18. Who Will Finish With More Rings? (LeBron wins 4-3)

I believe that Kobe will add another ring to his collection this year, giving him four.  I can not see LeBron ending his career with more than four so I will give this one to the Black Mamba.  A lot of people do not understand just what it takes to win a championship, let alone three.  My Take: Kobe

19. Whom Would You Rather Have On Your Pick-up Team? (LeBron wins 4-3)

ESPN analysts Henry Abbott made a great point that changed my mind on this one.  I was going to take Kobe, but his comment:

“Whom would you pick? The super intense guy who often reams out his teammates … or the freakishly big, strong guy who passes willingly and loves a good joke?”

made me change my pick to LeBron.  He knows when to laugh during a game but can also turn that switch and take over a game.  Regardless of who I pick, my team has a pretty good shot at winning this pick-up game. My Take: LeBron

20. Who Is The Truer Heir to MJ? (Kobe wins 6-1)

I fully believe that Kobe is the closest player we will ever see to MJ.  LeBron is flashy, gets the crowd involved, and has some pretty cool basketball shoes, but the way Kobe handles himself and acts on the court is very much like MJ.  I do not think either will ever be considered better than MJ, but Kobe is closer. My Take: Kobe

21. Who Would Win A One-on-One Game? (Kobe wins 5-2)

Kobe has the best mid-range jumpshot in the NBA and that would be key for him winning a game against LeBron.  Bryant does an excellent job guarding James when the two meet in games so I do not think the size factor would come into play as much as one would think. My Take: Kobe

22. One Game, One Guy: Whom Would You Pick? (LeBron wins 4-3)

Just because of what Kobe has been through in his career, I give him the nod today.  In six years, I probably go with LeBron but he just is not experienced enough.  Sure, he has been to the Finals but look how he fared in that.  Kobe is as clutch in big games as they come.  My Take: Kobe

23. 24 Seconds to Play, Down Two: Who Gets The Ball? (Kobe wins 6-1)

The way I looked at this question was who is going to give me the best chance of tying the game up for my team.  That guy is LeBron.  No one is better than A) winding down the clock and pulling up from 25 feet out and B) driving to the hole and drawing a foul.  Because of those two factors, I’ll take LeBron getting me two points at the end.  My Take: LeBron

24. Who Gets The Last Shot? (Kobe gets 5-2)

Now this question is different from the last.  For a last second shot, outside of MJ, there is no one else’s hands I would want the ball in more than Kobe.  He is as clutch as they come and has the experience to take the last shot.  It would probably go in, too.  My Take: Kobe

Kobe and LeBron should go down as the second and third best players of all-time.

Kobe and LeBron should go down as the second and third best players of all-time.

25. Who Is Better? (LeBron wins 4-3)

Ugghhh, they would ask this at the end, wouldn’t they?  At the beginning of the year, I would drop everything to watch LeBron and within about two minutes of watching, he would have my jaw on the ground with something amazing he did.  However, the more I thought about it, being flashy does not make you better.

Don’t get me wrong, LeBron is right at the top of the list and you can clearly make a case for him as the best player basketball in the world.  The point is that even though LeBron can jump out of the gym and resurrect a franchise in five years, Kobe still does it all.

He has been through SO much in his career and still perseveres through it all.  Maybe he has me fooled, but I believe he is a great teammate and even better person that has everything you look for in a superstar.  My Final Take: Kobe

*It was interesting to note that of the 25 categories, LeBron had my vote in seven of the 11 non-basketball related questions.

When it came to basketball related questions, Kobe had seven of my votes compared to six for LeBron.  The two most important questions, in my opinion, also went to Kobe (more rings and last shot).


May 26, 2009 - Posted by | Basketball, LeBron James, Los Angeles Lakers, NBA | ,


  1. dude…..lebron kobe in football you yake kobe???? who are you???

    Comment by bmillz | May 26, 2009 | Reply

  2. Just don’t think LeBron would be quick enough with his size. Maybe defensive end but Kobe’s got the quickness to do it. Close call.

    Comment by strotty | May 26, 2009 | Reply

  3. 23. 24 Seconds to Play, Down Two: Who Gets The Ball? (Kobe wins 6-1)

    The way I looked at this question was who is going to give me the best chance of tying the game up for my team. That guy is LeBron. No one is better than A) winding down the clock and pulling up from 25 feet out and B) driving to the hole and drawing a foul. Because of those two factors, I’ll take LeBron getting me two points at the end. My Take: LeBron

    Let’s get serious. LeBron is great at dribbling out the clock and stopping on a dime to pull up for a 25-foot jumper, but realistically, how many times is he going to hit that? On top of that, you can’t seriously say you would have confidence in him to hit two free throws to tie the game that late. Maybe you should check this article out…

    Comment by r1zzo23 | May 26, 2009 | Reply

  4. Lebron played WR in high school. Ran a 4.5 and was recruited by numerous D1 schools, USC being one of them lol. Pretty easy pick.

    Comment by logan | August 20, 2009 | Reply

    • Thanks for the comment. In his day, Kobe never played football and focused solely on basketball. Actually, he would have been a pro soccer player had he not moved from Italy. Who’s to say Kobe wouldn’t have become an excellent football player as well? The size is there and the speed is there more than LBJ. Tough choice, but I can just picture Kobe going nuts.

      Comment by strotty | August 20, 2009 | Reply

  5. I agree with you on the leadership thing, I have been saying that for a while now that Kobe really is a good leader. He has a lot of good talent to work with, and being a Kobe fan I have noticed him take the reigns more and accept that responsibility and be serious about it, if LeBron was a better leader than Kobe the Cavs would have a ring, they has some good talent. And no LeBron fan can call Kobe a ballhog, no need to explain further on that one.

    Comment by Drew | October 16, 2009 | Reply

  6. 1. How can you say Kobe would be a better football player. LeBron is 6’8” 260. I dont know how you can be to big to play reciever if you still have the athletic ability. And we all know KING James has the athletic ability. The dude has hands, i think he can really fly, and hes stong as shit! If he’s to big to play reciever then put him at tight end. Or put him at QB or even center Im sure he could do it. I mean the man can do everything he’s even an amazing bowler.
    2. How can you say Kobe would be the better teamate and better person. Kobe had a fude with big daddy Shaq when they were on the same team. Thats not healthy for a team. Also Kobe was charged with rape. And sure some people dont believe he raped her but even if he didnt rap her he still cheated on his wife! What has LeBron done to not earn this.
    I respect your thoughts though!

    Comment by matt willoughby | February 26, 2010 | Reply

  7. Check out my blog i just wrote up a blog about the Black Mamba vs. The Chosen One.

    Comment by matt willoughby | February 26, 2010 | Reply

  8. I thought this blog was interesting. I disagree with some of your points, but you defend them all fairly well. I liked seeing another person’s perspective/comparison with Kobe and LeBron. Saying truly who the better player is though is hard because they both have such high demand on the court and that’s what stands out. I don’t think you could call either one “better” than the other

    Comment by Meganne | April 14, 2010 | Reply

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: